There are a lot of people complaining about the current mappool on XS4ALL.
So, to keep it all a bit less annoying with a huge pile of complaints on one desk, let's post here your most favourite mappool and let's see if there can be some pool that will be ok for everyone. IF that is possible since it's megahard to keep everyone satisfied. But let's at least try...

Hmm.
I'm a horrible starter for the topic.
I don't even know the names of the maps.
Oh dear.
All I know is a few that I like

dm4
dm6
ultrav
aerowalk

And don't get me wrong, i really do like more maps than that, but I just don't know the names, sorry.

Please post your list of how you think the mappool should be.
What maps REALLY have to be in it.

imp1dm6 is under rated and works very well for little FFA (3-6 players)

Here are the results of our finnish jury

<Boidii>
1. ts-bunker
2. shine
3. dm5
4. four
5. ultrav
6. dm4
7. pkeg1
8. dm2
9. dm6
10. dm1
11. a2
12. ztndm3
13. aerowalk
14. dark-storm-ffa

dm1,2,3,4,5,6,7
e1m2,3,4,5
e2m2,7
e3m1,2,3
e4m3,5
ukcldm2

bring up some classic shit!!

let me add a map i think its very funny and works well on ffa (it was on xs4all mappool some years back):
SLOPY

I think my q3dm14 remake could work aswell. Since it will never played in any official league my work wouldnt be for noting.

http://www.quakeworld.nu/forum/topic/4385/remake-q3dm14

ztndm3
ztndm6
dm4
pkeg1
a2
dark-terror-ffa
cmt4
headshot
ukooldm6
asylum
xl1dm2
dm3
efdm8
death32c

Obviously these maps are of different sizes, ideally you'd want the map pool to skip certain maps if there are too few/many players present.

(Edited 2012-04-19, 13:59)

start
end
dm2
dm4
dm5
dm7
e1m2 Castle of the unnamed
e1m5 Gloom keep
e1m7 House of Cthon
e2m1 The installation
e2m7 The underearth
e3m2 The vaults of zin
e3m4 Satan's dark delight
e3m7 The haunted halls
e4m3 Hell's atrium
and perhaps
aerowalk
dark-storm-ffa
ztndm3
skull

(Edited 2012-04-19, 17:34)

The list of Couscous:

[16:42:27] <couscous> to go: xmastree, hohoho, dark-terror-ffa and dark-storm-ffa
[16:43:03] <couscous> ztndm1 and ztndm6 to go too perhaps
[16:43:37] <couscous> maps in: warfare, del1, ts-bunker, castle
[16:43:58] <couscous> e1m7
[16:44:02] <couscous>
[16:49:39] <couscous> dranzdm8 too
[16:50:47] <couscous> like a crazy outdoor ultrav

death32c
dm2
dm4
dm6
ztndm3
ztndm1
cleaver
e4m3
e1m5
e1m2
ultrav
dark-terror-ffa
dark-storm-ffa
crocktear
aggressr
q3dm6qw
kikdm3
zerdm5
dranzdm6
ramses2
q1edge
many ore i cant remember the names of

other episode maps
Generally speaking, more "weird" maps and a larger map pool, even the best maps can get repetitive.

dm1,2,3,4,5,6,7
e1m3,4,5
e2m2,7
e3m1,2,3
e4m3,5
ukcldm2
aerowalk
ztndm3
cmt4

go classic!

The mappool has been changed.
With a thank you to Bigfoot.

(And please don't ask me what maps are in the pool now.. so far I have recognised ZTNDM3, DM4 and DM6)

Edit: The new maplist is great. Love it, thank you thank you. As expected, there is already a lot of complaints because people can't find the rl's

(Edited 2012-04-21, 17:31)

Yippie! q3dm14 <3

What I wonder is why the windtunnel-effect (trigger_push) doesn't work anymore - not on ANY map?????

Time to revive this thread!

As you all know, I hate to complain incessantly about the map pool, but I do have some constructive suggestions for improvement:

• Replace 'dark-terror-ffa' with 'castle'.
• Replace 'dark-storm-ffa' with 'ts-bunker'.
• Replace 'slopy' with 'head-shot'.
• Replace 'e1m2' with 'e1m7'.
• Replace 'e3m2' with 'a2'.
• Replace the oft-skipped 'death32c' with 'spinev2'.
• Finally, put the new 'subterfuge' map somewhere suitable

(Edited 2012-08-22, 16:19)

I agree with couscous, but don't replace dark-terror-ffa. And add q3dm6qw ^_^

(Edited 2012-08-22, 21:32)

Leave dark storm alone. I love to idle at RA/PENT and remove everyone who want to distrub.

E2M7 and that weird map that is leaning has to go, always voted off.

Map pool also feels extremely small, or is it just me always dropping and joining at the same maps?

I agree, the map pool is too small.

Current map pool is IMO ok but I'd add:
Hook - bring back this map, please!!!
A2

rwild would be nice